Water filter pitcher for cloudy lava lamps

[Gooboy]

I have heard several folks say they cleared their cloudy LL's simply by running them through

a Brita (or equivalent) water filtration pitcher and it works great!

 

So, instead of a Brita, I decided to give this one a try since it has much higher ratings:

 

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002U50QQQ/ref=s9_simh_co_p60_d0_i...

 

This experiment is kind of expensive since I am sure to go through a few filters just for one

Grande lamp, so if it does not work, all you guys who say it does, are going to be in trouble :) LOL!

 

 

[Kempton]

Stanley I personally dont know. I think Rici knows she was talking about it on chat yesterday

[Rici Faulkner]

You need a PUR.  Nothing else but a PUR.  And it does relieve a great deal of the cloudiness.  It wont be sparkling clear like the older US lamps, but it will be a hell of a lot better than it was.

The PUR pitcher costs about 15 bucks and the replacement filters run about $15 for two on Amazon.

[Kempton]

Rici how did the 20 oz goo?

[Rici Faulkner]

Well...like I said...it is not 100% clear, but then again, it was EXTREMELY cloudy and I only filtered it once....but now instead of the liquid looking like skim milk, it is pretty clear and I can see my hand through it....so I would say it was a success for someone who is ok with a tiny bit of cloudiness....or just doesn't know any better.  The movement of the lava is great...or at least as great as a 20 oz flow will ever be.

[Gooboy]

Did you try running it through a 2nd time?

These all have the same basic filter chemistry, just different shapes to fit their machine.

I dont see any reason why one brand would work and better, or less, than any other, unless

this PUR has a different type of filter from all the rest!?

Anyway, I already have a unit on the way from my friends at Amazon.

Rici Faulkner said:

You need a PUR.  Nothing else but a PUR.  And it does relieve a great deal of the cloudiness.  It wont be sparkling clear like the older US lamps, but it will be a hell of a lot better than it was.

The PUR pitcher costs about 15 bucks and the replacement filters run about $15 for two on Amazon.

[Gooboy]

What exactly is a MSR pump?  :\
Marcel said:

With the MSR pump you get a 100% crystal clear lamp ;) Buts its a bit expensive :/

[Rici Faulkner]

I really should have looked at the filter you ordered a little closer before I replied, but I know that PUR is way better than Britta because of the two-part filtration.  It claims to remove many more impurities than the Britta does. If I can find the website where I saw the comparison chart on what impurities each brand of filter removes I will post it.  So that is why I am biased toward PUR, and I do know for certain that the PUR works.  However, I am sure the filter you ordered was fine, so I retract my previous "PUR only statement." and I wish you much luck in the process.  Personally, I would LOVE to get my hands on one of those pumps but the least amount of money I have seen them go for is about $50.  I would not mind spending the money for the pump if I had an important project like a Grande...but I was only dealing with a couple of 20oz China lamps, so I didn't really care about them much.  If they were not given to me as gifts, I would give them away to someone

[Modulo '70]

I tried my cloudy purple Astrobaby through a Brita water filter and it actually ended up much Cloudier and no longer flows properly!

[Gooboy]

Oh no, I didnt need to hear that :(

I was thinking that the charcoal in the filter may actually filter out some of the surfactant, since they are large

molecules. I dont know what the particle size filtration it does, so you are right, it may do more harm then good!!

 

Oh well, I have my GooKit ready, 3 gal of distilled water, and more goo colors in the mail ;)

ALPHA CENTAURI of the LAVAERIONS said:

I tried my cloudy purple Astrobaby through a Brita water filter and it actually ended up much Cloudier and no longer flows properly!

[Rici Faulkner]

Stanley....I just looked really hard at your water pitcher...and it is a REALLY good one...but I also kind of said to myself...maybe too good.  I will tell you this....I did two 20oz lamps through the PUR and they both are much clearer, and they both work very well.  The lava flow, like I said, does not seem to be reduced, and I did not need to "top off" the globes after I returned the water back into the globe. Everyone who posted about using a water pitcher on this site always go with the PUR filter, so I followed suit and had pretty good results. But if you are nervous about doing this procedure with your precious Grande (and I would not blame you at all)...then at least you have a top of the line water pitcher and you can enjoy some fresh, crisp H20.  I am so sorry i could not give you any better advice, but I don't have experience with the pitcher you bought, so I can't really say what the results would be, you understand?  That is why I was pushing the PUR filter because I KNOW for certain that they don't remove the surfactant significantly.  Sorry I couldn't help more.

[Gooboy]

You mean one of these?

 

http://www.amazon.com/PUR-CR-6000-2-Stage-Oval-Shaped-Water-Filtrat...

 

These are pretty cheap, I could just send the other one back since I prefer to use exactly the same method as

everyone else.

You may be right about the more expensive being TOO good! :) That's okay, Amazon is great about returning stuff :)

Rici Faulkner said:

Stanley....I just looked really hard at your water pitcher...and it is a REALLY good one...but I also kind of said to myself...maybe too good.  I will tell you this....I did two 20oz lamps through the PUR and they both are much clearer, and they both work very well.  The lava flow, like I said, does not seem to be reduced, and I did not need to "top off" the globes after I returned the water back into the globe. Everyone who posted about using a water pitcher on this site always go with the PUR filter, so I followed suit and had pretty good results. But if you are nervous about doing this procedure with your precious Grande (and I would not blame you at all)...then at least you have a top of the line water pitcher and you can enjoy some fresh, crisp H20.  I am so sorry i could not give you any better advice, but I don't have experience with the pitcher you bought, so I can't really say what the results would be, you understand?  That is why I was pushing the PUR filter because I KNOW for certain that they don't remove the surfactant significantly.  Sorry I couldn't help more.

[Gooboy]

After a bit of snooping around, I am wondering if the water inside the Grandes are the same formula as the smaller

lamps!? Maybe I better not risk it unless I get another replacement from Paula.

She already replaced my super cloudy purple/yellow (the new one is cloudy too, but not near as bad) and I am also

expecting my blue/yellow to be replaced.

So then I will have 4 Grandes to play with. But I am GooKitting the worst one for sure.

It s totally worthless, cant even see the lava unless it up close to the glass. Then you can see something moving

inside but cant tell what it is.

This is one I have been running for 3 weeks and no clearing!!